Breast Manual Pumps Comparison – Top 7

Breasts pumps are used by lactating women for a variety of reasons to extract breast milk. There are two different kinds of pumps, electrical and manual. However, manual breast pumps are more affordable compared to their counterparts.

What is the best manual breast pump?

There are many brands that are considered the best of the best because they are all trusted to operate well and last a long time. Because of this fact, it can make it difficult to choose between the brands Medela, Lansinoh, Ameda, Freemie, and Ardo. However, Ardo tends to come out just ahead of the bunch as their products are well made and repeatedly tested to work wonders. All in all, these choices are great, and the higher quality of each makes it hard to go wrong when choosing one of these brands.

Ameda One-Hand Manual Breast Pump With Flexishield

  • Ameda One-hand Breast Pump47.12$
  • FSA approved
  • 1breast/1 hand
  • Easy-to-use ;
  • Vary the frequency and degree of the squezze;
  • Compact

Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump

Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump

  • 46.59$
  • 1 breast/1 hand
  • BPA and BPS Free
  • Two-phase technology: stimulation and expression modes;
  • Pump-Store-Feed system;
  • 2 ComfortFit Flanges;
  • 2 Lansinoh mOmma®Bottles;
  • Breastmilk Storage Bag samples;
  • Bottle Stand

Medela Harmony Breast Pump

 Medela manual breast pump

  • 37.99$
  • FSA approved
  • 1 breast/1 hand
  • Lightweight;
  • portable;
  • Two Phase Expression technology

Medela LactinaDouble Breastpump Kit

Medela Double breast pump

  • 67.95$
  • FSA approved
  • 2 breasts/1 hand
  • BPA free
  • Single or double pumping;
  • Two valves;
  • User can pump breastmilk and store in the same container;

Freemie Equality Manual Pump Deluxe Set

Freemie manual breast pump

  • 88.45$
  • FSA approved
  • 2 breasts/1 hand
  • Single and double pumping;
  • silent;
  • easy to use on the go

Ameda One-Hand Breast Pump with Dual Hygienikit Milk Collection System 

Ameda double manual breast pump

  • 79.99$
  • FSA approved
  • 2 breasts/1 hand
  • BPA and DEHP free
  • Unique silicone diaphragm;
  • single or dual pumping

Ardo Amaryll Manual Breast Pump

Ardo manual breast pump

  • 49.95$
  • 1 breast/1 hand
  • BPA free
  • Efficient;
  • easy-to-use;
  • comfortable;
  • optiflow;
  • brush for cleaning

Is it Good to Use a Manual Breast Pump?

Like all breast pumps, it is good to relieve the breasts of the milk that they carry, especially if they are engorged. Using a breast pump to relieve engorgement is ideal even if the milk cannot be used to feed the infant for medical reasons. For many women who cannot use their breast milk to feed, they might merely “pump and dump” the milk to relieve the discomfort.

The good thing about manual pumps is that they allow the user to control the applied pressure to their breasts. Because they can cause less discomfort, they are sometimes preferred by women despite requiring much energy to operate, as their power source directly comes from the operator. Manual breast pumps are smart to use for a variety of reasons, whether it is storing milk for a baby while the mother works or merely relieving pressure from engorged breasts.

What Types of Manual Breast Pumps Exist?

When it comes to manual breast pumps, there are single or double pumps. It is more common to find manual pumps that have a single head, and they tend to be more affordable. If they have a hand-operated pump, they usually almost resembling a bicycle horn.

Double pumps tend to be one-hand-operated pumps that can pump both breasts simultaneously. Despite being more expensive, they tend to be preferred because they take less time and require less effort to operate. Truthfully, choosing between these types of pumps comes down to what you can afford and how often you intend to pump your breasts. If it is not a regular occurrence, it is recommended to use a single pump.

Manual vs electric breast pump

Many women have asked if mechanical breast pumps are better than manual pumps. The truth is that while each type of pump is excellent, mechanical pumps are merely not needed by everyone. It is far better to buy what you require for your own needs. If you are infrequently pumping, a manual pump is cheaper and easier to store.

Pros of Electric Pumps

  • They require no effort to pump.
  • Pump simultaneously.
  • Good for mothers who need to pump regularly.

Cons of Electric Pumps

  • Electric pumps can be a little more uncomfortable to use.
  • They are far more expensive than their manual counterparts, costing hundreds of dollars.
  • They take up a lot more space while stored away in your home.

Pros of Manual Pumps

  • Manual pumps can control the pressure and pace that breasts are pumped, making them an excellent choice for those who are sensitive.
  • They are very affordable.
  • Good for those who do not need to pump very often.

Cons of Manual Pumps

  • They require the user to operate them physically.
  • In some manual pumps, the rubber suction bulb can cause infection as it can be hard to clean.
  • Sometimes they cannot offer sufficient stimulation to empty the breast of milk.